'Another Difficult Journey to Nowhere:' One Journalist's Account of Life in Gaza

By: Sharon Moshavi | 10/24/2024

Just months before the war, Naaman Ashtawy of Gaza was one of several newsroom leaders taking part in an ICFJ program on media sustainability.

Now, the ICFJ network member operates his photo agency from what has become one of the world’s deadliest conflict zones.

Photos shot by Naaman’s team at APA Images have been published in outlets ranging from CNN and Deutsche Welle to The Guardian, at a time when Israel has largely barred foreign media from Gaza. As Naaman told us recently: “Journalists in Gaza play a tremendous role in showing the world the horrors of this war, and they are paying a price.”
 


Earlier this year, Naaman was injured by shrapnel in his face, arm and leg during an Israeli bombing at Al Aqsa Hospital that also wounded two of his team members. Later, he and his colleagues fled the hospital as Israeli forces drew near.

“We are on another difficult journey to nowhere,” Naaman wrote to us at the time. “We’re still considering all options, while trying to keep our operations going as much as possible. Absolutely no place in Gaza is safe.”

Naaman’s situation is harrowing, and not unusual.

According to the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), since the war began at least 128 journalists and media workers have been killed in Gaza, the West Bank, Israel and Lebanon, including some targeted by Israeli forces. The killings of journalists, who are civilians under the law, must stop, and Israel must investigate cases of journalists killed by their forces.

The overall death toll is, of course, vastly higher: More than 42,000 Palestinians and 1,200 Israelis have been killed since Oct. 7, 2023, when Hamas attacked Israel and seized about 250 hostages and Israel declared war in response. Tragically, the humanitarian situation in Gaza is catastrophic, more than 60 living hostages remain in Gaza, and the conflict is now intensifying in Lebanon as well.

Amid Israel’s restrictions on foreign media, Palestinian journalists are the eyes and ears of this devastating war. ICFJ, in a letter signed by more than 60 media and civil society organizations, called on Israeli authorities to immediately end these restrictions, which place “an impossible and unreasonable burden on local reporters to document a war through which they are living.”

I hope you will take a moment to read Naaman’s story, written by Sherry Ricchiardi, as well as those of other journalists. As the war approaches its 14th month, we can’t look away. 

News Category

Latest News

How to Deal with Mis- and Disinformation in Times of Uncertainty

There is evidence that disinformation is designed to take advantage of our emotions. It also tends to spread farther and more rapidly during times of change and uncertainty. When people have questions and there are gaps in information, the disinformers (those who profit from lies), take advantage, “magically” putting forth what appear often to be simple answers or solutions. Here are some tips to protect yourself from falling for or sharing false or alarmist content as the U.S. transitions into a second Donald Trump presidency.

Insights into Journalism and Advice for Student Reporters Heading into 2025, from ICFJ Knight Fellows

As we kickstart 2025, we asked our ICFJ Knight Fellows about their outlooks for the new year, and what challenges and/or opportunities they’re preparing to face head on. The Fellows also provided their topline advice for student and early-career journalists to succeed in today’s news industry.

ICFJ Announces Its Inaugural Cohort of Boost Reporting Fellows

Journalists from Gambia, Bangladesh and Ecuador will pursue reporting on climate-related issues with support from ICFJ’s Boost Reporting Grants.