Catch 22

By: Bruno Garcez | 09/16/2010

On Saturday, the 11th, the Mural project reconvened in Folha de São Paulo's training room.

The biggest daily newspaper in Brazil once again hosted a group of reporters from peripheral communities of São Paulo.

A total of 24 participants were selected. The profile ranged from bloggers, community organizers, journalists and students. All of them from peripheral communities and shanty towns in the Greater São Paulo area.

The eagerness of this group to engage in these discussions about their day to day became clear from the earliest hour.

As usual, we started the day by looking into the day's newspapers and checking what - if anything - had been covered about communities on the outskirts of São Paulo.

There were few stories, as the students quickly pointed out, apart from the usual police themed headline. That lead to a very productive, if heated, debate.

Our discussion, as student Cleber Arruda accurately pointed out in a post he wrote for the Mural blog, talked about all the constructive things that are taking place in their communities, but that are sidelined by the mainstream media.

Cleber also recalled another heated discussion on a ''Catch 22'' dilemma that we see on an almost daily basis on the country's newspapers.

Is the coverage on communities outside of the more affluent parts of the city somewhat monothematic due to a lack of readers in peripheral communities?

Or is there a lack of coverage because most of the readers of the mainstream media come from middle class boroughs?

If we add to this supply and demand issue bits of bias, prejudice and, last but not least, laziness, and accommodation, we end up with a very nasty combination that has lead to the current scenario.

Cleber points out that it's as if editors of the big publications asked themselves if it would be worth it to think outside the mold, if the subjects portrayed in such stories are not even likely to read them. And if the ones who do read their papers do not identify with such livelihoods or would rather carry on seeing such communities as safe havens for crime and violence.

How can we work ourselves of this trap? By acknowledging that the emergence of millions of people out of extreme poverty is likely to have an influence in the news cycle and the news coverage as well.

That many of the São Paulo inhabitants currently being stigmatized by the city's publications have an increasing will to be heard and to express themselves.

Of course, the lack of cultural foundations and the deficiencies in the educational system faced by several people in outlying communities does them no favors.

But with the social transformations already taking course, certainly more is to come.

Mural, its participants have realized that a true change is going to come, not made possible by politicians, but by inhabitants taking their fates in their own hands.

The time is now to make the best of this wave of change.

Latest News

ICFJ se Suma a Otras 9 Organizaciones Internacionales Para Presentar un Amicus Curiae en el Caso del Periodista Guatemalteco Encarcelado José Rubén Zamora

Un grupo de 10 organizaciones internacionales presentó esta semana un amicus curiae ante la Corte Suprema de Justicia de Guatemala en el caso del periodista José Rubén Zamora Marroquín. El amicus, presentado el 26 de marzo, argumenta que el retorno de Zamora a prisión preventiva constituye una violación de sus derechos fundamentales bajo el derecho guatemalteco e internacional, e insta a la Corte a otorgar un recurso de amparo pendiente y permitir que el Sr. Zamora lleve su proceso bajo medidas sustitutivas.

ICFJ Joins 9 Other International Organizations in Submitting Amicus Brief in Case of Imprisoned Guatemalan Journalist José Rubén Zamora

A group of 10 international organizations submitted an amicus curiae brief to Guatemala’s Supreme Court in the case of journalist José Rubén Zamora Marroquín. The brief, filed on March 26, argues that Zamora’s return to preventive detention constitutes a violation of his fundamental rights under Guatemalan and international law, and urges the Court to grant a pending amparo appeal and allow Zamora to return to house arrest.

Press Freedom on Campus: Why it Matters and What Student Journalists Need Most

In February, ICFJ partnered with Vanderbilt University and Freedom Forum, with support from the Lumina Foundation, to bring university faculty and students, international and U.S. journalists, and media leaders together for a discussion about the importance of press freedom in democratic societies. Participants stressed how U.S.-based journalists can learn from the experiences of their colleagues abroad, and they dived into the challenges campus reporters face, such as a lack of funding and harassment from fellow students, offered advice for engaging audiences, and more.